A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms: Season 1

It is the year 209 After the Conquest, eighty years after the Dance of Dragons and eighty-nine before the War of the Five Kings. The realm of the Seven Kingdoms is at peace. To celebrate his daughter's nameday, the Lord of Ashford is holding a great tourney, and knights and lords of renown from across the realm are arriving to show their prowess in personal combat and jousting. Amongst them are several princes of House Targaryen, now dragonless but still holding the Iron Throne...and a newly-anointed hedge knight by the name of Ser Duncan the Tall. Dunk sees to acquit himself well in the lists, but his lack of coin makes his prospects precarious. A chance encounter with a young boy named Egg, who volunteers to squire for him, changes his fortunes, and those of the Seven Kingdoms themselves.

For the third time, HBO has decided to visit the lands of Westeros and create a new hit television series. Set in the same world as Game of Thrones (set later) and House of the Dragon (set earlier), A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms adapts the Dunk & Egg series of novellas by George R.R. Martin, with three currently published. This first season of six episodes adapts the first and best (to date) novella in the sequence, The Hedge Knight (1998), and tries once again to right the ship that is Westeros-on-TV after a shaky previous season.

Once again, HBO has defied the odds and delivered a stand-up season of quality television. Here writer and showrunner Ira Parker, working with George R.R. Martin and Ti Mikkel, amongst others, has had to thread a needle of creating something that's identifiably part of the same world as the other shows whilst also ploughing its own path and unique identity. He is helped here by the source material, which is exceptional. The Hedge Knight may be George's strongest piece of writing in the world of Westeros and Essos, and maybe even his finest piece of writing as a whole. It's a story operating on multiple levels as Dunk has to consider the price of honour in a land where violence is still used to solve problems, and fairness and justice are relative concepts. The novella moves its pieces around with precision which click into place at the end in an artistically satisfying way.

At first, the TV take on the same story feels like it's a little stretched. Extensive new flashback sequences explore Dunk's background in Flea Bottom, a rough slum in King's Landing (the previous, or rather future, home of characters like Gendry and Davos), and his period as squire to Ser Arlan of Pennytree. Multiple new subplots have been inserted into the story of the tourney itself, with Dunk refusing an offer for an opponent to throw a match to satisfy the betting crowd and seeking wise advice from the local working girls. More minor characters in the novella like Ser Raymun Fossoway and Lord Lyonel Baratheon, the Laughing Storm, are here fleshed out in greater detail, with distinct character arcs of their own. The show also leans into the lighter and less-ominous tone with more humour, including a lot of toilet humour (quite literally, in some cases)

This expansion of the novella is good, in that minor characters are given more depth and more motivation for helping Dunk, but it does slow down the action. One of the novella's strengths is how it moves with a purpose, says its peace and is done. The TV show slows things down perhaps a tad too much in its opening episodes, with the impact of making the episodes feel both too short (only one exceeds 40 minutes, and several barely crack 30) but also risking feeling like there is too much filler.

This problem quickly evaporates in the third episode, however, as the main plot from the novella kicks into gear and suddenly the season catches fire and does not let up. The infamous tourney battle which is the centrepiece of the novella is rendered here as one of the finest medieval combat sequences ever staged on the screen, with a refreshing use of helmets (often inexplicably absent from Game of Thrones) and intelligent use of weapons. The plotting is impressive, dialogue often poetic and the acting throughout is outstanding, particularly by Peter Claffey as Ser Duncan the Tall and Dexter Sol Ansell as Egg, both outrageously good finds. Bertie Carvel (Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norell) is also outstanding as Prince Baelor "Breakspear" Targaryen, Daniel Ings is a very different Lyonel Baratheon from the book but a compelling performer, and Youssef Kerkour excels in a small role as the blacksmith Steely Pate.

The production values, as you would expect, are excellent. That this is a cheaper show than House of the Dragon and the last couple of seasons of Thrones is to be expected. There are no dragons in the story and the whole show takes place in one castle and the field next door, as well as some miscellaneous Northern Ireland scenery. But it's clearly not cheap. There are vast crowds of spectators, the extras budget alone must have been exceptional, and there's a lot of action sequences involving trained fighters and horses. HBO are their most relatively frugal for this franchise, is still capable of delivering stunning imagery. Dan Romer also delivers a superbly atmospheric soundtrack.

But what makes the show work the best is the relationship between Dunk and Egg. Claffey and Ansell sell the characters' relationship extremely well, with Dunk's pragmatism and idealism (or naivete) counterpointed by his inexperience, whilst Egg's book smarts lacking real-world application is charmingly handled. When the season ends, you immediately want to see more of these characters and their adventures. And there's good news on that, with Season 2, based on The Sworn Sword, already in production for a 2027 release.

The first season of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (****½) has a slow start but quickly picks up, delivering a relentless battery of well-judged character moments, action, worldbuilding and pathos. It's refreshing to take a visit to a time in Westeros's history when decency and compassion are still respected, and the two leads should be well established for great careers by their performances here. The show is currently streaming around the world and will be released on DVD, Blu-Ray and 4K in the summer.

Thank you for reading The Wertzone. To help me provide better content, please consider contributing to my Patreon page and other funding methods.