Earth, 2100. Mega-City Two, the vast super-conurbation stretching down the west coast of North America, has fallen victim to a malevolent plague. Mega-City One has developed an antidote, but the airspace over the mega cities is contested, so the only way to deliver the plague is overland, through the radioactive, burned-out wasteland separating the two: the Cursed Earth. Obviously only one man is capable of undertaking this epic journey: Judge Dredd. But whilst Dredd is away, there are those back in Mega-City One taking advantage of his absence...
The first volume of The Complete Case Files introduced the insane techno-hellscape of crime-ridden Mega-City One and its enforcers of law and order, the Judges. It's probably fair to say that volume is not the best introduction to the world of Judge Dredd, featuring as it does overwhelmingly violent action stories designed to appeal to teenage boys in the late 1970s. Subtlety, in-depth worldbuilding and strong thematic development were not high on the agenda, and the franchise showed little of the satirical bite and intelligence that would characterise it at its best. Still, it showed some promise, especially when it delved into Dredd's backstory or moved away from crime-of-the-week capers towards longer narratives, like the Robot Wars arc.
By contrast, Volume 02 is just two massive narratives, with a few one-off stories between, and is immediately much better for it. Much of the first half of the volume is taken up by The Cursed Earth, which runs from Prog #65 to #85, and is the first critically-acclaimed Dredd epic. Heavily inspired by Roger Zelazny's Damnation Alley, it sees Dredd taking a road trip from Mega-City One on the Eastern Seaboard to Mega-City Two on the west coast, bringing urgently-needed vaccines to the sister-city.
Despite being classified as a single saga, the story is really a themed collection of episodes, linked by the device of the journey. Early on Dredd has to deal with mad mutants living in the Appalachians (where Mount Rushmore has been moved for unclear reasons), robotic vampires serving the last President of the United States, Mississippi plantationers using enslaved aliens, a cloned dinosaur theme park in the Rockies where the dinos have escaped and run amuck (did Michael Crichton read 2000AD?), and shenanigans in Las Vegas where the local Judges have gone rogue and become their own Mafia-like gang.
There's definitely a lot more dark satire here than in the first volume, and in fact the volume has to legally omit the most problematic storyline, in which it's revealed the pre-nuclear-war rivalry between local McDonalds and Burger King franchises has escalated into full-scale actual warfare. One infamous scene has a guy dressed as Ronald McDonald executing an employee for spilling a milkshake. Another episode, also omitted, has a mad scientist who looks like Colonel Sanders creating evil creatures based on corporate mascots, including the Green Giant and the Michelin Man. Rebellion did somehow negotiate the rights to use these elements in The Cursed Earth Uncensored edition from a few years ago (now out of print), but The Complete Case Files sadly has to make do without. The episodic nature of the story does mean you don't really notice their absence.
The story is solid, and some of the satire is quite biting, with alien slave Tweak and his story of enslavement in what is effectively the American South (if one reduced to a post-apocalyptic waste) being quite on-the-nose for the late 1970s. We also get a nice amount of worldbuilding by meeting President Booth, the leader of the United States when the third and last world war broke out, and explanations for how Dredd's world evolved out of ours.
If the story has a problem, it can be a little repetitive, goes on a little too long and the defaulting to using explosive ultraviolence to solve every problem can get predictable. Still, the sheer unhinged lunacy of some aspects of the story, like Judge Dredd facing off against a killer mutant tyrannosaurus, is quite entertaining.
The story rolls almost immediately into The Day The Law Died, which ran from Prog 89 to 108. After some odd cases back in Mega-City One hinting that not everything has been running smoothly in Dredd's absence, the city is taken over in a coup by Deputy Chief Judge Cal. Cal initially appears competent, but quickly goes totally insane, enforces the death penalty for the most ludicrous infractions, has alien mercenaries enforce his rule, and appoints his pet goldfish to second-in-command of the city. He neutralises Dredd early on, forcing Dredd to go underground and form a resistance to try to retake the city.
Cal is - fairly blatantly - based on the Roman Emperor Caligula, which may seem random until you remember that the BBC mini-series I, Claudius had been absolutely huge on British TV just two years earlier, with John Hurt on superb form as the deranged Caligula.
The story is again a bit overlong, and suffers a bit from the infamously fractious people of Mega-City One, who normally make the citizens of Springfield, Pawnee and Star's Hollow look quiet and orderly in comparison, going along with Cal's crazy stunts far too meekly. I get the impression the writers agreed and we get a late-story retcon trying to explain how everyone has been put under Cal's spell, but as an idea it's a bit weaksauce.
Instead, the story is mostly an excuse for action and for the development of a larger cast of secondary characters, including the introduction of Judge Griffin, as well as some crazy setpieces and comedic ideas, like Judge Fish, or Judge Schmaltz living up to his name to Dredd's extreme frustration.
By the end of Volume 02 (***½), we're still not up to speed with Dredd at his best, but we're getting closer. The few cases-of-the-week are unremarkable, but the two extended sagas are both solid stories with some great worldbuilding and side-characters. Both stories are probably a bit too padded, and the suspension of disbelief required to accept that Cal would get away with half the things he does before someone shoots him is quite strong, but we're seeing the comic start the development of its satirical bite and darker undertones that will become a much bigger part of its appeal later on.
The Complete Case Files Volume 02 contains almost every Judge Dredd story printed from Prog (issue) 61 to Prog 115 of the comic 2000AD, published from April 1978 to June 1979. Progs 71-72 and 77-78 are skipped because of legal issues (these stories riff hard on MacDonalds, Burger King and Kentucky Fried Chicken, with scant respect for trademarks). The stories are set in the years 2100 and 2101. The writers in this collection are John Wagner, Pat Mills and Chris Lowder. The artists in this collection are Dave Gibbons, Mike McMahon, Brian Bolland, Brendan McCarthy, Brett Ewins, Garry Leach and Ron Smith.
Thank you for reading The Wertzone. To help me provide better content, please consider contributing to my Patreon page and other funding methods.
No comments:
Post a Comment