Matt Murdock hangs up the mantle of Daredevil after a personal tragedy and so he can focus on his work as an attorney in New York City. The unexpected election of convicted ex-convict and former crime lord Wilson Fisk to the position of Mayor brings Murdock - and Daredevil - back into play.
The Netflix-Marvel collaborative series Daredevil (2015-18) was a huge success, a premium TV show featuring one of Marvel's most interesting and conflicted characters. Superb casting, including for-the-ages performances from Vincent D'Onofrio, Charlie Cox, Jon Bernthal and Deborah Ann Woll, rewarded it with a committed fanbase and a whole slew of spin-off shows, including Jessica Jones, Luke Cage, Iron Fist and team-up mini-series The Defenders, though the quality of these shows became increasingly questionable. With Marvel's parent company Disney launching a rival streaming platform, these shows entered a canonical limbo, with Disney reluctant to commit to them being official in the Marvel Cinematic Universe even after they regained the rights to air the shows on Disney+ and started using Cox and D'Onofrio in other projects.
Daredevil: Born Again, insanely, started off as a reboot of the previous show using some of the same actors (but randomly recasting others) in a new continuity. Fortunately, sanity prevailed and the entire Marvel-Netflixverse was moved into the mainline MCU canon. Less fortunately, this decision was made only some time into the show's production, resulting in substantial reshoots, some actors replaced by their original counterparts and a lot of work needing to be done to have the resulting story make sense.
Your view of Born Again's first season will likely depend on your appreciation for the above. On the one hand, that the season is as cohesive and well-acted as it is, is nothing short of miraculous. On the other, there's a distinctly off-kilter feeling in the season as it moves between newly-shot material (mostly book-ending the season) and trying to incorporate the original concept of a more episodic series with stand-alone cases. In practice this really only survives with an episode about Murdock trapped in a bank (without his Daredevil gear) during a robbery, which ironically might be the best episode of the season. Other storylines feel a bit all over the place, with Vanessa Fisk's infidelity feeling particularly like a storyline that eats up time without bringing much of value to the series.
The disjointedness can also be found in the casting: Deborah Ann Woll's Karen Page is the heart, soul and sometimes common sense of the series, but she spends most of the season benched in San Francisco. Jon Bernthal's Punisher also makes a welcome return, but has little to do. More successful is the introduction of serial killer Muse and his pursuit of therapist Heather Glenn (Murdock's love interest for the season), resulting in a morally murky, emotionally conflicted storyline that is quite successful.
Elsewhere the season's biggest success is Wilson Fisk. That Vincent D'Onofrio has made this character his own, imbuing him with menace but also a rough charm and a romantic (ish) heart, was well-established a decade ago. Here he has to play Fisk with restraint and political savvy, as his go-to solutions of violence and terror may have worked as Kingpin, but cannot fly as Mayor. There's a whole bunch of subplots about Fisk's staff, who are won over by his charm but also scared of his reputation, which work surprisingly well. Putting constraints around Fisk and watching him try to operate within those constraints is a clever move which helps overcome the vague feeling that Marvel know what they have here and are risking over-using it (a much bigger problem in the subsequent season).
The integration of the sub-franchise into the wider MCU is also a mixed bag. Bringing in characters like Swordsman and Ms. Marvel's family are interesting moves, but with the show now fully integrated into the wider universe, questions like, "where the hell is Spider-Man?" (especially since Murdock met Parker in the last movie) feel more germane than they were during the original show, without many good answers.
The season finale is pretty strong, seeing Fisk finally deciding how he is going to use his newfound status and power, and Murdock calling on his full array of allies for help, setting up a potentially more interesting second season.
Daredevil: Born Again's first season (***½) is not the slam-dunk, home run fans of the Netflix original series may have been hoping for, with some messy pacing and side-plots that don't feel well-developed. That a large chunk of the original cast is missing is also frustrating. But some of the new characters are interesting, D'Onofrio and Cox's formidable charisma are always fun to watch on-screen and some great groundwork is laid for future seasons. The season is available on Disney+ now.
Thank you for reading The Wertzone. To help me provide better content, please consider contributing to my Patreon page and other funding methods.
No comments:
Post a Comment