Friday, 20 November 2026

Legacies of Betrayal by Steven Erikson

Rebellion threatens - yet again - to consume the vast subcontinent of Seven Cities. High Fist Arenfall leads a stalwart defence against the threat from the city of G'danisban...but far to the west, a lowly Malazan outpost on the edge of the Jhag Odhan receives a visit from three Jaghut. Their arrival, along with that of a batch of fresh marines from allies the Malazans forgot they ever made, helps spark a march to Y'Ghatan, the ever-burning city, where powerful forces are, as usual, converging. The Malazan Empire has to act quickly to crush this new threat as word comes of new problems arising in distant lands.

Legacies of Betrayal is the third of four books in the planned Witness sequence, a sequel-of-sorts to Steven Erikson's shelf-bending Malazan Book of the Fallen decalogy. This book wasn't originally planned to exist, but instead spun out of No Life Forsaken for reasons that have not been fully confirmed. The first, eyebrow-raising thing about the book is its short length, clocking in at under 300 pages in hardcover, making it, very easily, Erikson's shortest novel to date. Combined with No Life Forsaken, the combined tome would have still been either the shortest or second-shortest novel Malazan Erikson has written, behind only Gardens of the Moon, so the question arises, why was the novel split?

The more commercially-minded might be looking at the escalating costs of paper and Erikson's position as a fantasy author whose profile and intensity of online discussion is massively out of keeping with his actual sales, not helped by his prequel novel Fall of Light significantly underperforming back in 2016. Erikson's publishers may have put their foot down on how long his books can be, though it still feels like forcing him to split a still-moderately-sized fantasy novel into one normal-sized book and one ultra-short one is a weird decision. I don't think the margins are that fine.

Erikson himself has claimed the split was done for artistic reasons, and I think this has more weight to it. No Life Forsaken was a more serious, weighty book dealing with more serious themes of colonisation, imperialism and self-determination. Legacies of Betrayal is the Keystone Kops but with Malazan marines filling in the role of the bumbling police officers. Combined in one volume, the shift from tragic pathos to mind-boggling comedy would have been rather jarring.

So in this book we have a group of Malazan marines led by minor Book of the Fallen character Dunsparrow in all their standard, bickering glory, but who then join forces with representatives of the Madrabaladrogan Empire, an underground microstate that the Malazan Empire was unable to fully subdue so allied with instead, which everyone promptly forgot about. These guys are basically Erikson's take on dwarves, following on from his highly original takes on elves (with the Tiste), orcs (the Jaghut) and dragons (Eleint). These guys are interesting, but given how much stuff is going on in this (very slender) tome, they don't get that much development. Both forces are then joined by three Jaghut. Regular Malazan readers will know a single angry Jaghut can freeze an entire continent, so even the Malazans step lightly around three of them being in the same room at once, as they try to discern the Jaghut objectives.

An alternate title for the book might have been Legacies of Hypercompetence, because for once the Malazans don't have too many nasty surprises. We have a hypercompetent military force (even by Malazan standards) joined by hypercompetent superdwarves and three hypercompetent immortal glacier-summoners from before the dawn of time. Just to make sure the deck is fully stacked in our heroes' favour, one of the Malazan marines is a Malazan Book of the Fallen all-timer fan favourite who is only marginally less powerful than a Jaghut by themselves. Oh, and multiple gods are keeping an eye on our team. The bad guys, basically consisting of a dodgy priest trying to conduct a ritual in literally the worst place on the continent to do so and some random bandits, are outclassed from before the prologue preamble stops.

The removal of any effective suspense doesn't stop the book being readable. This is Erikson's least introspective novel, ever (though there is still some, this is only relatively), as there's just no time for it, and the comedic focus is enjoyable, at least to start with. Erikson's sense of humour can be an acquired taste and in the mainline books it is a nice seasoning on the themes of tragedy, compassion, historical irony and the futility of war. Here it's a bit overpowering, not helped by Erikson feeling like he's breaking out some of the Old Favourites. When Iskaral Pust reappears with his broom, touching base with a joke that Erikson made in the year 2000, some readers will no doubt appreciate it and others may be wishing for some new material.

The book certainly does not outstay its welcome, and the ending feels decidedly rote. The Malazans curbstomp, a god shows up randomly to negate a late complication that threatened to raise the stakes to a more interesting level, gnomic utterances are uttered and there's a round-robin of comic interludes. It's all very okay.

The book does come alive the most in its epilogue, which revisits The God is Not Willing and gives some more context to those events, which is quite a good moment. But some may feel it's a bit late in the day.

Legacies of Betrayal (***½) is a conflicting book. It's funny, but some of the humour outstays its welcome. The examination of cultural clashes, the legacy of an old war threatening to spark a new one and so forth, are all handled better in No Life Forsaken. Dramatic tension is in short supply. If may be Erikson's most lightweight book to date. But it's still well-written, there's some good dialogue, some effective (if brief) battle sequences, and some random cameos from the mainline Malazan sequence will raise smiles. I'd probably just advise waiting for the paperback.

Thank you for reading The Wertzone. To help me provide better content, please consider contributing to my Patreon page and other funding methods.

No comments: