BioWare was founded in Edmonton, Canada in 1995 by Ray Muzyka, Greg Zechuk and Augustine Yip. Their first game, Shattered Steel, was a mech combat title, published by Interplay Entertainment in 1996. Their second title was planned to be a fantasy roleplaying game with the working title Battleground: Infinity, using impressive new tech that was quickly dubbed the Infinity Engine. Interplay, impressed by a demo, suggested merging the game with their own Dungeons & Dragons video game licence. The resulting game, Baldur's Gate, was released in late 1998 and was hugely critically acclaimed, enjoying strong sales. Arguably, this was the first game to come close to nailing the atmosphere of playing a tabletop game of D&D. The game also had a robust multiplayer mode, allowing people to play different characters at the same time in a classic D&D party. BioWare developed an expansion pack, Tales of the Sword Coast (1999), and a fully-fledged, far more ambitious sequel, Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn (2000), still regarded as one of the finest video games of all time. Baldur's Gate II also received its own expansion, Throne of Bhaal (2001), which brought the story to an end (for twenty years, anyway).
In the meantime, Interplay licensed the Infinity Engine for their inhouse development team, Black Isle Studios, to develop their own Dungeons & Dragons games, giving rise to Planescape: Torment (1999), Icewind Dale (2000) and Icewind Dale II (2002). Collaboration between the two companies remained strong and BioWare began development of Neverwinter Nights (2002), their first 3D title. However, Interplay lost the D&D licence to Atari, who published Neverwinter Nights instead. Interplay and Black Isle went into financial freefall and collapsed in 2003, ironically whilst working on Baldur's Gate III: The Black Hound and Fallout 3: Van Buren, neither of which was ever finished.
BioWare had entered into discussions with LucasArts and in 2003 released Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, an epic roleplaying game set 4,000 years before the events of the films. Released at a moment when the franchise was at a low critical ebb, due to the perceived two disappointing prequel films, the game received enormous praise for its writing and central plot twist, which some held to be better than Empire Strikes Back's twist. Surprisingly, BioWare passed on developing the sequel, instead recommending Obsidian Entertainment, a new company set up by their friends who had escaped the collapse of Black Isle and Interplay. Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords was released in 2004 and began Obsidian's own storied (though bumpier) journey through the RPG space.
By this point BioWare had made the strategic decision that they were spending too much money on licences for other people's properties, and decided to develop their own worlds from scratch. This resulted in Jade Empire (2005), an Asian-influenced hybrid of roleplaying game and martial arts brawler. The game was critically well-received, but the RPG hardcore audience disliked the streamlining of RPG mechanics and the general audience seemed confused over the game's genre. Though it did okay, it did not meet BioWare's sales expectations and plans for a sequel were dropped.
BioWare's next game was Mass Effect (2007), an epic RPG that was an effective spiritual successor to Knights of the Old Republic, but in an original science fiction universe. Again, the RPG hardcore was let down by the removal of even more RPG mechanics, but the game's character creation system, dialogue choices, writing, worldbuilding and hugely iconic plot twists, which the player could influence, were all hugely praised. The game, originally published in a deal with Microsoft, sold quite well and attracted the attention of Electronic Arts, who acquired BioWare in late 2007.
One of the prevailing narratives through the years since has been that EA interfered significantly in BioWare's internal development. Upon acquiring the studio EA learned that their in-development game, a spiritual successor to Baldur's Gate called Dragon Age: Origins, was planned to be a PC-only title, despite having been in development already for several years and had spent a large amount of money. EA mandated the game be released on consoles as well and a marketing campaign filled with blood and gore was launched, which some people felt heavily misrepresented the tone and style of the game. Appalled at the game's budget, EA also demanded a "quickie" sequel to be developed in just one year. Dragon Age: Origins (2009) was extremely well-received reviewed on PC, but the console ports were criticised for being underwhelming. Dragon Age II (2011) was even more fiercely criticised for heavy reuse of limited assets, being a much shorter game than Origins, and removing a lot of RPG mechanics in favour of lots and lots of combat.
In between, BioWare released Mass Effect 2 (2010), possibly their single most well-received game, which featured greatly improved combat and a companion character mechanic which saw the player have to recruit a dirty dozen to take on an alien threat, with tremendous freedom in which characters to select and how to use them in the final mission, with differing numbers of casualties and outcomes possible. However, during the development of this game, development started of a Star Wars online multiplayer game, and the Mass Effect franchise lost some of its main writers to the new game. Star Wars: The Old Republic was released in 2011 to some good reviews and reasonable sales, but a lot of fan scepticism, especially those who perceived the game would prevent the development of a "proper" Knights of the Old Republic III.
Mass Effect 3 (2012), which concluded the epic story begun in the first game five years earlier, launched to a storm of controversy with players incensed that the complex choices players had made through three games was reduced to choosing one of three options at the very end of the game, and the game being thematically incoherent with the ideas being laid down in the earlier titles, which they blamed on some personnel (particularly chief writer and worldbuilding Drew Karpyshyn) being moved over to the Star Wars game. BioWare responded to the criticism by issuing patches rewriting the ending to acknowledge more of the players' choices, though ultimately it could only go so far. A few months later, the remaining BioWare founders at the company all quit.
Dragon Age: Inquisition was released in 2014 and was the company's biggest-selling game. Despite this, the game suffered criticism for being too big and long, an overreaction to Dragon Age II's shortness, and by being an open-world game, chasing the appeal of Skyrim, whilst not having game systems well-suited for that format. The game's critical cachet improved markedly with the release of its expansion, Trespasser (2015).
Mass Effect: Andromeda was released in 2017 and received fierce criticism for a likewise dramatic change to the series' structure, pursuing a similar open-world environment, albeit this time on multiple planets. The game was also criticised for having weaker characters than the trilogy, and by removing the action to the Andromeda Galaxy and some 800 years further in the future, many fan-favourite characters, species and ships were missing from the title. The game also launched in a heavily-bugged state. The game's critical cachet has improved somewhat in subsequent years, and its combat has been praised as the best in the series, but the game's financial underperformance was a bigger problem it could not solve. Anthem, a multiplayer shooter based around jetpacks, was released in 2019 and was the company's biggest failure to date, launching with an anemic amount of content.
The company rallied in 2021 for Mass Effect: Legendary Edition, a comprehensive remaster and re-release of the original trilogy as one game, optimised for modern systems. The remaster was regarded as a success, introducing the franchise to a new generation and selling well.
In 2024 BioWare released what would prove to be their final game: Dragon Age: The Veilguard. The game had been developed as a multiplayer title before pivoting to a single-player focus, and the game was criticised for weird pacing, an unusual visual aesthetic compared to the previous games and some odd mechanics and gameplay ideas that may have been remnants of the multiplayer focus. Though not completely without merit, the game's critical reception was dubious and its commercial success dire.
BioWare had confirmed they were working on a new Mass Effect game that would feature a return to the Milky Way Galaxy and would be a more direct sequel to the original trilogy, with some OG characters returning. In 2025, Amazon Television confirmed that a Mass Effect TV series was also in development. It was well-known inside and outside the company that "Mass Effect 5" (the final title would have likely been different) was the studio's last chance to shine, and failure would likely mean the shuttering of the company.
However, it's now clear that Electronic Arts had decided not to even give them that chance. Despite releasing a teaser trailer for the game in 2023, no new footage or information about the game had been released in over three years. Today's storm of news stories confirm that the game was in "early" development nine years after the release of the previous game in the series, which was clearly unacceptable. EA themselves may have been responsible for this, putting the studio through rounds of lay-offs after Veilguard's release that may have simply made it impossible for them to make a brand new AAA game. Some of today's reporting suggests that only 50 employees were left working at BioWare, clearly far too few to even consider the game in full production. Some reporting indicates that EA had been rotating BioWare personnel into other studios and projects for some time.
BioWare's obituary will be simply having created some of the greatest video games of all time. Baldur's Gate I and II, Knights of the Old Republic, all three Mass Effect games (despite the ropey ending) and Dragon Age: Origins are all-timer classics of the genre. Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Dragon Age II and Mass Effect: Andromeda are also all pretty solid games in their own right, if not of the same calibre. Dragon Age: Inquisition was also well-received, though I must confess that in my several attempts to play the game, I bounced off it pretty hard.
BioWare's legacy is also in the studios that it inspired. Without BioWare's early help and recommendations, Obsidian Entertainment would have likely never survived and achieved the things they did. CD Projekt Red also owe their existence to BioWare, having started off as the Polish localisation team for the Baldur's Gate games before licencing BioWare's Aurora Engine for The Witcher (2007), which was published by Atari on BioWare's recommendation. Larian Studios mooted their Divinity series as a spiritual successor to the Baldur's Gate games which led to them getting the licence to make Baldur's Gate III, an absolutely massive giga-success on release in 2023. Fans and personnel at BioWare themselves both asked why BioWare wasn't making that game instead. Other companies exist thanks to BioWare veterans, such as Beamdog (founded by ex-BioWare vets to release successful remasters of Baldur's Gate and its sequel) and Archetype Entertainmen, who will release their Mass Effect spiritual successor Exodus in April 2027.
The feeling, fairly or not, was that since at least the EA takeover in 2009, BioWare could no longer take creative risks and they were constantly funnelled into chasing trends rather than establishing them. Inquisition's open-world pivot was a response to the success of Skyrim, whilst Anthem was chasing the success of the likes of Destiny (without any understanding of why that was a success). EA, whose most successful franchises were online shooters and sports games, were an awkward fit for BioWare from the start. However, some commentators have cautioned on this as an overly simplistic narrative, pointing out that Anthem was a project originated by BioWare themselves and pushed by leadership at the studio.
Certainly BioWare's dramatically slowed release cadence was a problem; they released seven games in their first decade, ten in their second but then only three in their third (four only if you count a remaster). Sales were also an issue: Inquisition was, by far, their biggest-selling game but never cracked 20 million units, less than a third of Skyrim. Most of their games stayed under 10 million units sold. It did sometimes feel that BioWare was often treated and reported on as an AAA industry-leader developer but its sales never really reflected that (unlike Bethesda, CD Projekt Red post-Witcher III, Blizzard etc). This wasn't a problem when budgets were low and their release frequency was high, but as their budgets shot up and their release schedule elongated to ridiculous timespans, the situation clearly became untenable.
It will be interesting to see if EA does anything with the franchises it now owns in full after BioWare's dissolution, or if interested third parties try to acquire those series to do something with them. Whilst the company is gone, its games remain, and many of them remain solid gold classics.
No comments:
Post a Comment